- Season 1 Episode 10: A Very Ex-Amish Christmas
Jonas rethinks his decision to leave his family as he faces Christmas alone, while Michaela seeks her mother's approval over her wish to join the Amish
- Season 1 Episode 9: Family Affairs
A father and son experience the world outside their Amish community, while a teenager gets a week-long taste of life with the traditionalists
- Season 1 Episode 8: Living Fast
Former Amish leader Moses Gingerich takes on the tough task of comforting the grief-stricken group when a tragedy hits the community
- Season 1 Episode 7: Change of Faith
Mose ponders the role religion and spirituality play in the lives of Amish and ex-Amish alike, and takes a long hard look at his own conflicted beliefs
- Season 1 Episode 6: Mending Fences
Moses visits his ex-Amish cousin who has recently returned from serving in Afghanistan, and is inspired to visit his mother for the first time in nine years
- Season 1 Episode 5: Amish in Public
Mose receives an invitation to give a lecture at Indiana University, while Esther gathers the courage to pursue her dream of becoming an actress
- Season 1 Episode 4: 9-to-5 Amish
Michaela struggles with adjustment issues when she goes to stay with Rachel, a traditional Amish woman; Mose reaches out to his old community but finds they've shut off all contact with him.
- Season 1 Episode 3: Can't Go Home Again
An ex-Amish teen is involved in a serious car crash that leaves him fighting for his life. The accident devastates his former community who see cars as a threat to their traditions
- Season 1 Episode 2: Culture Clash
Michaela, a non-Amish teenager with a troubled family history longs to join the Amish community; Cephas Yoder finds his dream of owning some land hard to realize.
- Season 1 Episode 1: Amish 101
The Columbia, Mo., ex-Amish community includes two brothers trying to help a friend leave the sect and a man who still yearns to return to his Amish family after five years outside the sect.